Updated: Mar 15
Global Brands make Marketing mistakes too
Where was the concept testing?
In both cases major failures have occurred costing millions of pounds & irreversible brand damage. My first thought having read up on both was how did their testing processes go so wrong?
No 'i' in team? Or just no ideas?
It makes me wonder about the make up of the teams they had in place, whether they were made up of the sorts of people who felt they could challenge the ideas they were seeing, & how limited the consumer testing element must have been. The following is a quick recap of what has occured.
Nike created a trainer 'Air Max 1 Quick Strike Fourth of July' featuring the Betsy Ross flag
The Betsy Ross Flag has in the past been associated with extreme right wing Amercia.
After the trainers release it was immediately pulled from sale following criticism from Colin Kaepernick a high profile sports star.
Quoting The Wall Street Journal
“After images of the shoe were posted online, Mr Kaepernick, a Nike endorser, reached out to company officials saying that he and others felt the Betsy Ross flag is an offensive symbol because of its connection to an era of slavery.”
From scanning Twitter however it appears many Americans would defend the trainer and Nikes choice to use the flag.
The decision to can the shoe has apparently lost Nike the opportunity to build a manufacturing plant in Arizona after the governor Doug Ducey (source USA Today) pulled his support of Nike.
“Instead of celebrating American history the week of our nation’s independence, Nike has apparently decided that Betsy Ross is unworthy, and has bowed to the current onslaught of political correctness and historical revisionism,”
Ducey wrote in a series of tweets early on Tuesday.
Adidas created an online campaign where they allowed users of Twitter to put their own Twitter handles on the back of a virtual shirt, which was then tweeted out from the @adidasUK account.
The sports company's campaign backfired terribly as shocking messages appeared on the back of the new Gunners shirt. Twitter has launched an investigation after Arsenal’s adidas kit launch was hijacked by racist social media users.
The personalised design was even available to order as part of their ‘Dare to Create’ campaign.
There were also references to Madeleine McCann and the Hillsborough disaster.
An adidas spokesperson told the Huffington Post: “As part of our partnership launch with Arsenal we have been made aware of the abuse of a Twitter personalisation mechanic created to allow excited fans to get their name on the back of the new jersey.
“Due to a small minority creating offensive versions of this we have immediately turned off the functionality and the Twitter team will be investigating.”
Complete failure of testing
You would imagine that a company like Nike would have vigorous consumer testing of their designs before they even got to the stage of being made up into a shoe wouldn't you?
Feedback is so important to any company big or small.
What you can learn from Nike is that its really important to seek a large range of feedback, dont just ask your employees because they may not tell you what they think immediately.
This has been referred to before in works such as Malcolm Gladwells Outliers. Lower status employees may be scared to tell their higher ups that they dont like an idea.
Cult of personality is such that big characters at a senior level may create a culture where those below dont want to disappoint so they dont critisise an idea.
What can you learn from Nike & Adidas?
1) Feedback is important - Show lots of people your ideas before launch! Get feedback from a large pool. You don't have to act on it but someone might just catch a huge failure before it gets through the net.
2) Create Dialogue -Make sure you have proper feedback loops in place with your customers, nurture a relationship of asking people what they think about things, create dialogue, maybe consider formalising it with panels and groups who agree to provide you with feedback.
3) Don't blindly allow user generated content to go live! - I am so surprised that the team at Adidas didn't see the chance for mischief with their campaign idea.
It is not the first time hashtags have been misappropriated. Trusting people to only use a hashtag for good seems very naive.
And the time it took them to actually react and get this offline is also of concern. Surely a company of this size has the resource to employ moderators?
4. Create diversity of everything in teams - Make sure the team you work with have a range of experience, you may miss something but someone else may have seen it before and nip it in the bud. Make sure your teams are from lots of backgrounds and have lots of experience in the right field. Surely anyone who regularly uses Twitter could have seen this coming?
Singing for my Supper
If you enjoyed reading this article and maybe others I've written, found a tip that worked for you or learned something new, it would be great if you'd consider sending me the price of a cup of coffee :) https://www.paypal.me/thanksforreading/2.50
What to read next
How to be more creative is something we all ponder. Why not learn about how we create in this new blog about Netflix series The Creative Brain
Shona Chambers Marketing is a Marketing Agency based in Nunhead near Peckham. Specialising in helping Small Business Owners and Freelancers with their Marketing. Based at 61 Cheltenham Road, Peckham, SE15 3AF